4 merge requests!12First publish without edit,!7Add: Abstract and Introduction,!5Master-1 : change the Abstract,!4Draft: Review Branch with all changes from main against empty
This thesis investigates cost-effective and high-performance alternatives to ImageSharp for image processing in software applications. While ImageSharp is a versatile and widely adopted library, its annual licensing fees impose significant financial burdens on projects. The research aims to identify alternative solutions that deliver comparable or superior performance while fulfilling core image processing requirements.
Comparing different image processing librariesis an important job that has to be done to find a solution which is on the one hand cost-effective and on the other hand high-performing that would be appropriate for the industrial and software applications. Automation, quality control, medical imaging, and real-time data analysis are the use cases involving digital image processing, and it requires the libraries that can give both efficiency and elasticity. Whether they are open-source or proprietary, the libraries such as OpenCV, SkiaSharp, Magick.NET, Emgu CV, and OpenCvSharp give a wide spectrum of functionalities, from simple image manipulations to complex computer vision problems.
The study begins with a detailed analysis of ImageSharp’s capabilities, including image loading, creation, manipulation, pixel access, resizing, format conversion, and image composition. These operations underpin tasks such as image transformation, cropping, and metadata management. To evaluate alternatives, the research establishes performance benchmarks focusing on critical operations like image conversion and pixel iteration.
The choice of a graphics programming library that is applicable to a given task is primarily influenced by several factors (the first of which is) the computational efficiency used in the algorithms, as well as licensing, and integration concepts as well. Some libraries take into account the speed and flexibility and thus cater to performance-critical applications whereas others are more centered on the ease of use and support for different platforms. To test the performance of libraries, you will be needed to measure their run-time, memory usage, and requirements for different environments, including embedded systems, desktop applications, and cloud-based platforms.
Several libraries were evaluated, including Emgu CV, SkiaSharp, Magick.NET, and OpenCvSharp. Each library was assessed for key factors: advanced image processing capabilities, performance, licensing costs, integration complexity, and community support. Benchmarks were conducted to measure execution times and efficiency across various image manipulation tasks.
A key consideration in the industrial context is the trade-off between the processing power and the stability in the setting of the operation. On the one hand, with the help of the high-performance computers, the image transformation can be done in a flash and the real-time analysis can be done but, on the other hand, embedded systems and industrial controllers always set limits that make the execution slow. It is crucial to make the necessary trade-offs between these three in the case of such companies, which approach the issue of image processing optimization by factoring in reliability and cost efficiency.
The results identified Emgu CV and SkiaSharp as the most effective combination to replace ImageSharp. Emgu CV, leveraging the powerful OpenCV framework, excels in high-performance image operations such as pixel manipulation, resizing, and format conversion. SkiaSharp complements Emgu CV with its efficient 2D graphics rendering and image composition capabilities. Together, they provide a comprehensive solution that balances functionality, cost-effectiveness, and high performance.
Benchmarking demonstrated a significant improvement in execution times compared to ImageSharp. For instance, image conversion times were reduced to 490 ms, a substantial improvement over ImageSharp's 2754 ms. Similarly, pixel iteration tasks were executed more efficiently, highlighting the combination’s suitability for performance-critical scenarios.
In conclusion, this thesis identifies the Emgu CV and SkiaSharp combination as a superior alternative to ImageSharp. This solution not only eliminates licensing costs but also enhances performance, ensuring that software applications can meet demanding image processing requirements with flexibility and efficiency.
The research report is a comprehensive analysis of the image processing libraries. During the course of the project, the main strengths, weaknesses, as well as the best-use scenarios are seen. The results compile efficiency measurements, integration difficulties, and cost-related issues, offering a practical guide not only for software developers but also for hardware engineers and decision-makers who would like to principally survive the expanding market of image processing solutions in any type of industry across the world.
